Grab your free writing choice board set here!

Sub Day Rewards That Actually Work

Make sub days smoother with fun, low-prep incentives that boost behavior, help subs thrive, and keep your class excited while you're away!

SUBSTITUTE TEACHER

10/18/20253 min read

🎉 Make Sub Days Smoother with a Fun Incentive Twist!

Let’s be real—planning for a sub can feel like prepping for a space launch. But one little trick can make a galactic difference: a creative substitute incentive! A simple, fun reward system gives your students something to look forward to and helps your sub feel like they’ve got this (because they do!).

💡 Why Bother with a Sub Incentive?

Because it works—like, really works. When students know there’s a reward on the line, they’re more likely to stay focused, be kind, and follow directions. And that means your sub can spend less time managing behavior and more time actually teaching. Plus, you get to return to a classroom that didn’t go full chaos mode. Win-win-win.

📝 Keep It Easy-Peasy for the Sub

Your sub doesn’t need a 10-page manual. Keep it short, sweet, and crystal clear. A one-pager with what students can earn and how they earn it is perfect. Think: “If students do X, they get Y.” Boom. Done. The simpler it is, the more likely it’ll actually happen.

🎁 Make the Reward Feel Special

This is your chance to break out of the usual prize box routine. Sub day rewards should feel like a treat—not just more of the same. Think small but mighty: something your students don’t usually get, but will be so excited about.

🧠 Need Ideas? I’ve Got You!

Here are a few low-prep, high-impact sub incentives to try:

🎟️ Sub Tickets: Let the sub hand out tickets for kindness, participation, or awesome behavior. When you’re back, hold a quick raffle for a prize or privilege!
🏆 Class Goal Challenge: Set a team goal—if the class earns enough points, they unlock a group reward like extra recess, a dance party, or a cozy read-aloud.
🎁 Mystery Reward: Leave a sealed envelope labeled “Open if you have an awesome day!” The suspense alone will keep them on their best behavior.
📣 Sub Shout-Outs: Give your sub a sheet to jot down names of students who went above and beyond. Celebrate those shout-outs when you return!

🌟 Why It’s Totally Worth It

A little prep now = a whole lot of peace later. Your students know what’s expected, your sub has a plan, and you come back to a classroom that’s still standing (and maybe even thriving!). It’s a small system with big impact—and your future self will thank you.

🎉 Ready to Make It Happen?

I’ve got you covered! Grab my free Behavior Rewards Cards from TpT—they’re perfect for sub days and everyday classroom management. Easy to print, fun to use, and totally free!

👉 Click here to download your freebie!

Need more subbing Tips? Try these blogs!

How to Prep Your Class for a Substitute Teacher Day

Smart Prep Tips for Substitute Teachers

Easy, Interactive Ideas for Sub Days

🐿️ Squirrelly Says: Don’t Miss the Goodies!

Hi friend! I’m Squirrelly—the nutty little squirrel behind all the classroom magic here at Squirrelly Creations. I’ve been busy gathering the best teaching tips, seasonal freebies, and sneak peeks just for you. Want in on the stash?

📸 Click my picture below to join the Squirrelly Squad!

You’ll get joyful ideas delivered straight to your inbox (no tree climbing required). It’s cozy, creative, and totally acorn-approved. I promise not to bury your inbox in acorns. Just the good stuff.🌰✨