How to Use Roll-A-Story to Differentiate Writing Lessons

Let’s be real—teaching writing can feel like juggling flaming pencils. ✏️🔥 You’ve got students who can spin a tale faster than you can say “once upon a time,” and others who stare at the page like it just insulted their dog. That’s why Roll-A-Story is a classroom lifesaver.

This activity blends creativity, structure, and just enough dice-rolling magic to turn writing into a game. Students roll to discover their character, setting, and problem—and boom! They’re off on a storytelling adventure. Best part? Roll-A-Story is ridiculously easy to differentiate, so every student can feel successful.

💡 Why Roll-A-Story Is a Differentiation Dream

Roll-A-Story is built for flexibility. The dice give students structure and choice, which means:

• Emerging writers get a clear framework to guide their ideas.

• Confident writers get a launchpad for wild, imaginative flights.

• You get one activity that works across your whole class.

Perfect for:

• Whole-class writing lessons

• Small group instruction

• Independent writing centers

🐢 Supporting Struggling Writers (Without the Tears)

Some students need a little extra scaffolding to get those pencils moving. Here’s how to make Roll-A-Story feel doable and fun:

• Sentence Starters: Give them a jumpstart with opening lines that match their rolled prompts.

• Word Banks: Offer juicy vocabulary lists—think descriptive adjectives, action verbs, or dialogue snippets.

• Fewer Rolls: Pre-select one or two story elements to keep things simple and focused.

• Partner Writing: Let students brainstorm together before writing solo. Two heads = less stress.

These tweaks help students build confidence and avoid the dreaded blank page freeze.

🚀 Leveling Up for Advanced Writers

Got students who are ready to write the next great novel? Let’s challenge them to stretch their storytelling muscles:

• Extra Rolls: Add categories like “mood,” “genre,” or “plot twist” for extra complexity.

• Challenge Cards: Toss in bonus tasks—use a metaphor, include dialogue, end with a cliffhanger.

• Time Limits: Try quick writes to boost fluency and creative risk-taking.

• Double Rolls: Roll twice for one category and require both elements in the story. Plot twist meets pirate ship? Yes, please.

These add-ons keep your high-flyers engaged and experimenting with new styles.

🧩 Bringing It All Together

Differentiation doesn’t mean reinventing the wheel for every student. With Roll-A-Story, you’ve got one core activity that flexes to meet a range of needs. Whether you’re teaching whole-class, small groups, or running independent centers, you can adjust the level of support or challenge with ease.

Roll-A-Story isn’t just fun—it’s a powerful tool for helping every student find their voice, build confidence, and fall in love with writing.

✨ Your Turn!

Have you rolled out Roll-A-Story in your classroom? What tweaks or tricks helped your students shine? Drop your ideas in the comments—I’d love to hear how you make storytelling magic happen!

Need some more help?

Try reading these blogs for more info on using roll-a-story in your classroom and let the fun times roll!

Roll-A-Story: A Fun Writing Game for Kids

Roll a Story: Easy Prep, Big Engagement

🎲 Ready to roll with even more storytelling magic?

If you’re loving the sound of Roll-A-Story, you’ll want to check out my full collection of classroom-ready resources designed to make writing fun, flexible, and totally doable for every learner. From seasonal themes to differentiated supports, my custom Roll-A-Story category on TpT is packed with ideas to keep your students engaged and your planning stress-free.

👉 Explore the Roll-A-Story collection here and find your next classroom favorite

🐿️ Squirrelly Says: Don’t Miss the Goodies!

Hi friend! I’m Squirrelly—the nutty little squirrel behind all the classroom magic here at Squirrelly Creations. I’ve been busy gathering the best teaching tips, seasonal freebies, and sneak peeks just for you. Want in on the stash?

📸 Click my picture below to join the Squirrelly Squad!

You’ll get joyful ideas delivered straight to your inbox (no tree climbing required). It’s cozy, creative, and totally acorn-approved. I promise not to bury your inbox in acorns. Just the good stuff.🌰✨