5 Fun Ways to Give Students Choice in Writing Prompts

Let’s face it—nothing zaps writing time faster than a classroom full of blank stares and “I don’t know what to write!” sighs. But when students get to choose their own writing prompts? That’s when the magic happens. 💫

Giving kids ownership over their writing isn’t just fun—it’s empowering. They feel heard, they get excited, and suddenly writing becomes a way to express who they are (instead of just another assignment). The trick? Offering choice with structure so your classroom doesn’t turn into a free-for-all.

Here are five teacher-tested, kid-approved ways to let students pick their own prompts—while keeping things organized and joyful.

🎲 1. Roll-a-Story Dice

Let students roll their way into storytelling! Create a chart with categories like character, setting, and problem. Students roll dice to mix and match story elements into a one-of-a-kind prompt.

Why it works:

• Feels like a game 🎲

• Sparks creativity

• Gives even reluctant writers a clear starting point

Bonus tip: Add extra categories like “genre” or “plot twist” for your advanced storytellers!

🍽️ 2. Writing Prompt Menus

Serve up writing choices with a side of fun! Design a menu with “appetizers” (quick journal prompts), “entrées” (longer pieces like narratives or opinion writing), and “desserts” (creative extras like poetry or comics).

Why it works:

• Visual and easy to navigate

• Encourages variety

• Lets students “order” their writing while staying within your boundaries

Pro tip: Switch up the menu seasonally for a fresh twist!

🔄 3. Task Card Shuffle

Fill a box with writing prompt task cards. Students can draw one at random, swap with a partner, or choose from a small selection you’ve pre-picked.

Why it works:

• Low prep, high engagement

• Adds surprise and choice

• Great for centers or fast finishers

Want to level it up? Add challenge cards with bonus tasks like “use a simile” or “include dialogue.”

⬜ 4. Choice Boards

Create a 3x3 or 4x4 board filled with different writing prompts—narrative, informative, opinion, and more. Students choose a row, column, or diagonal (tic-tac-toe style!) to complete.

Why it works:

• Visual and structured

• Encourages balanced writing practice

• Easy to differentiate

You can even color-code prompts by difficulty or genre for extra flexibility.

📝 5. Student-Generated Prompts

Let students become the prompt creators! Brainstorm ideas together, or invite students to submit prompts anonymously into a class jar.

Why it works:

• Builds ownership and confidence

• Encourages peer-to-peer inspiration

• Turns writing into a collaborative experience

This strategy is especially powerful during themed units or seasonal writing celebrations.

🧠 Tips for Managing Writing Choices (Without Losing Your Sanity)

• Stick to 3–5 options at a time to avoid overwhelm.

• Use visual aids like menus, boards, or jars to streamline decision-making.

• Set clear routines so students know how to choose and get started quickly.

💬 Final Thoughts

When students feel like their ideas matter, their writing transforms. By offering structured choices, you’re not just boosting engagement—you’re helping kids discover their voice, build confidence, and fall in love with writing.

So go ahead—roll the dice, shuffle the cards, and let your writers take the lead. Your classroom will thank you.

🌟Your Writing Toolkit Just Got Bigger!

From choice boards to seasonal prompts, there’s always another way to make writing joyful. Explore more teacher-loved ideas to keep your students engaged, confident, and excited to write.

Easy Writing Choice Board Ideas for Teachers

Roll-A-Story: Dice Games for Young Writers

Boost Writing Skills with Story Starter Prompts

🐿️ Squirrelly Says: Don’t Miss the Goodies!

Hi friend! I’m Squirrelly—the nutty little squirrel behind all the classroom magic here at Squirrelly Creations. I’ve been busy gathering the best teaching tips, seasonal freebies, and sneak peeks just for you. Want in on the stash?

📸 Click my picture below to join the Squirrelly Squad!

You’ll get joyful ideas delivered straight to your inbox (no tree climbing required). It’s cozy, creative, and totally acorn-approved. I promise not to bury your inbox in acorns. Just the good stuff.🌰✨